2007??? Little out of date! That might actually pre-date the Salutation's refurbishment (although I'm not sure - it might have been 2005...).
I went to the Newshouse a couple of years ago wasn't overly impressed with the atmosphere, being comprised mostly of either fresh-off-the-train tourists or the type of old men who were either born in there or evolved from the dregs of the beer.
Cock & Hoop, never been there (although the name is worth a laugh).
Trip - you know my opinion!
Kean's Head - never heard of it (Lace Market area isn't a popular haunt for non-tourists like me!).
Bell Inn - you again know my opinion!
Gatehouse - I've heard of it but never actually been. Apparently it's one of those "upper class" places with overpriced fizzy beer and no REAL beer in it. Sounds like a "wine bar" to me!
Old Moot Hall - never heard of it, but I know the area well (I used to live in it). Not sure, but the area isn't one of the more "reputable" ones. Hey, it could be a diamond in the rough. Just make sure you keep a hand on your wallet when you leave.
Lincolnshire Poacher - never been there, but it looks like a real ale pub to me, so WIN! Anything named after a number station wins for me...
Sir Charles Napier - my god, that's a blast from the past. The "Napier" was one of the places we used to hang out at university. It's slap-bang in the middle of Trent University country and is a student haven. It's a bit out of the way, locked in the middle of student accommodation high-rises. The Saracen (just up the road) is the distant cousin of it that no-one talks about (my mate Max used to go there more often than the Napier). Nice enough area if you like students though.
The quality pub crawl, even until the last time I was in Nottingham was Trip -> Sal -> Bell -> Pit. All in roughly the same area (Market Square and surrounds). I think that Vat & Fiddle and maybe the Newshouse could be added to that. If Fellows, Morton and Clayton is still there (about 0.1m from station) then that's worth a visit. They brew their own and they do some very nice "special edition" beers.
Sadly, my "local" always was the Tap N Tumbler, but Brenda (the old owner) sold it and it's now under new management who have changed the "ambience". An old geezer pub up the road shut at about the same time and the old uns all migrated to the Tap. Not the same any more.
All that said, though, I'm easy with wherever the final decision is. I just wanna meet up with some of you guys.