Page 1 of 1

Mutabilis Chapter Six

Posted: Fri Aug 17, 2007 3:15 pm
by drew
Remarkable what you can do in a lunch hour if you remain focused...

I've uploaded and changed chapters one and five....

And here is Chapter Six (Link to the wiki page)

Cheers,

Drew.

edit 18.08.2007 @ 08:00 - Minor update for typo, clarity and style.

Posted: Sun Aug 19, 2007 8:05 pm
by Jack_H
Drew, watch out when you get heavy conversations going:

another issue to deal with.”
“That woman.”
“Zerz claims she is you.”
“That’s ridiculous. Madness!”
“He says she is a version of you from the future.”
“And you believe him? What a load of flux!”
“At this stage I’m not sure what to believe.”
“Oh for nova's sake! He’s the assassin! Let’s


its all talking. there is no reactions or movements, or pauses for thought at all. Jim has just told Rebecca that the other woman is her. Instead of putting her hand to his mouth, her eyes widening in shock or turning white, or even just dropping her jaw speechless, she sayss: "...ridiculous. Madness!"

now serious, would she say that? that line sounds so unnatural and fake it made me decide to stop reading and do some work. there is no emotion here and i really have no idea what rebecca is feeling. and she talks funny. I suggest you look at it again and really think about how someone would react to that kind of news. its going to catch them off guard. I guess if she was a victorian era housewife, she might speak like that, but i'm not sure if that is where you are going with rebecca. she seems to be the kind of girl that can get knocked off course.

anyway, something to think about.

Posted: Sun Aug 19, 2007 8:40 pm
by drew
Thanks Jack, I'll review it. I know what I was was trying to get across there, but obviously it didn't work! :oops:
its all talking. there is no reactions or movements, or pauses for thought at all. Jim has just told Rebecca that the other woman is her. Instead of putting her hand to his mouth, her eyes widening in shock or turning white, or even just dropping her jaw speechless, she sayss: "...ridiculous. Madness!"
Rebecca is in denial at this stage... hopefully made a bit clearer in the updated doc, and it's still possible that this woman isn't who she claims to be....

Cheers,

Drew.

Posted: Sun Aug 19, 2007 10:33 pm
by Jack_H
Ok a few more nitpicks coming up:

"Fully half of the central cargo bay of the Imperial Courier had been
converted into state rooms. It was decked out in something of an old
fashioned manner, with a sumptuous furnishings that would not have looked
out of place in some of the best old world hotels."

Fully here is redundant. to deck something out is colloquial and then you mix this with 'an old fashioned manner' which is not so colloquial. seems a bit disruptive to me.

"with a sumptuous furnishings" should be "with sumptuous furnishings"

and an aside nitpick: sumptuos furnishings doesn't really descibe anything to me: silk cushions? tapestries? curtains? couches? i would like to know what is sumptuous about them and what kind of furnishings they are. Are we looking at the den of an arabian sultan or the throne room of an english king?

Ok, you start describing afterward. perhaps you should look at rewording so you dont need to mentio they are sumptuous because that is redundant after you explain what they are.

"The centre piece of the room was a large rectangular table, which,
astonishing though it seemed, was made of real oak."

poor comma usage here. I think what you are going for is:

"The centre piece of the room was a large rectangular table, which astonishingly looked like real oak."

"variety of some" - totally redundant here. a variety by definition is 'some' of something.

"Even Jim, with his relatively opulent upbringing, didn't recognise some of
them. Rebecca was completely out of her depth.
The room was lit by a large chandelier, suspended"

who is the poing of view here? omnipotent? if so, ok, otherwise you have told us what two people aer thinking, which is impossible for a non-telepath. you could reword so Jim thinks to himself that his upbringing was good by any means and he was lost and he had no doubt that rebecca was completely lost.

"“Don’t start, harmless.” Rebecca said, pointing a finger at him,
snapping out each word slowly and glaring at him fiercely."

explaining how she said the words after she said them doesn't erally work for me..the effect is lost. perhaps:

"Rebecca stuck her finger out at him and glared. "Don't start, harmless," she said, snapping out each word slowly." I realise I still ahve the form of talking afterward, but i ahve broken up the whole line of explanation, which works better, i think.

"As they entered the central bay Zerz and the woman, ‘Bechs’ were
already seated."

Comma usage! "As they entered the central bay, Zerz and the woman "Bechs" were alerady seated."

Ok, that'll do for now. I won't be able to finish the story on my break if i keep this up!

Hope that helps

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 10:22 am
by drew
Yep, like most of that, but not all. Will make some adjustments and re-upload.

Edit : Uploaded...

Cheers,

Drew,

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 10:44 am
by Commander McLane
How many chapters are there to expect in total? I'm really looking forward to reading the whole story, but after chapter three or so I have given up reading the single chapters and decided to wait until it's finished.

So, any estimations on when it's going to be finished?

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 10:53 am
by drew
Commander McLane wrote:
How many chapters are there to expect in total? I'm really looking forward to reading the whole story, but after chapter three or so I have given up reading the single chapters and decided to wait until it's finished.

So, any estimations on when it's going to be finished?
Hmm..

I reckon probably another 4 chapters or so.. Given my current rate of progress that would be just before Christmas time. :shock: :cry:

Cheers,

Drew.

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 11:45 am
by JensAyton
drew wrote:
I reckon probably another 4 chapters or so.. Given my current rate of progress that would be just before Christmas time. :shock: :cry:
I know the feeling. ;-)

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2007 11:59 am
by Captain Hesperus
drew wrote:
I reckon probably another 4 chapters or so.. Given my current rate of progress that would be just before Christmas time. :shock: :cry:
I feel your pain. I'm working on a piece of Elite/Oolite fan-fic and every time I sit down to start r/l decides to start banging on the door and demanding time/attention/money/all of the above.

Keep at it though, Mutabilis is really shaping up to be a stormer!

Captain Hesperus

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 6:59 am
by drew
On that note, do people still want individual chapters posted, or shall I just wait until the story is finished and give you occasional 'progress updates?'

Cheers,

Drew.

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 9:40 am
by Star Gazer
Chapters are just fine by me, I'll devour anything worth reading, and I'm thoroughly enjoying Mutabilis!

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 9:58 am
by Captain Hesperus
Yes, chapter-by-chapter can be frustrating! As a heart-stopping revelation is unveiled, the chapter ends!!! But hell, the wait for the next chapter means I get to sit and speculate on what I'll read next and keeps me in suspense.

I say chapters all the way. :wink:

Captain Hesperus

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 10:35 am
by TGHC
I agree with the feline!

I always re-read the previous chapter(s) before starting a new one (the old memory's not what it used to be).

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 11:35 am
by drew
Ok, chapter by chapter is fine by me...
As a heart-stopping revelation is unveiled, the chapter ends!!!
Mean trick I know, but hopefully keeps up the excitement...!

Chapter Seven shouldn't take quite so long as six, as I had to write quite a lot of it to get my head around chapter six! Time travelly stuff was surprisingly hard to plot...

Cheers,

Drew.

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 7:54 pm
by Jack_H
I feel your pain there, Drew. (re time travelling)

I like reading each chapter as it comes up. I may forget what happens in previous chapters but as soon as is tart reading the next one, it all comes back.


those that dont want to read each chapter as it comes up dont have to read it, but giving the people who want it the option is the best course, IMHO