Oolite Bulletins

DaddyHoggy wrote:

mandoman wrote:

I find it interesting that Ahruman is against using the "smooth = yes" option. I think he was explaining it, but it went right over my head. What else is new

Look at the underneath of the snapper in the bottom of your posted pictures - it is very bright in one corner near where it joins the camo hull, but very dark in the far corner - this is what Ahruman meant and why overall smoothing doesn't necessarily work - that flat surface on the underside of the hull should be presenting a single angle to the sun and therefore should be evenly lit, but it's not. For your ship, where the engines and the dome stand out when they're not smoothed, this may still be the better option for you.

DaddyHoggy wrote:

mandoman wrote:

I find it interesting that Ahruman is against using the "smooth = yes" option.

Look at the underneath of the snapper in the bottom of your posted pictures - it is very bright in one corner near where it joins the camo hull, but very dark in the far corner - this is what Ahruman meant and why overall smoothing doesn't necessarily work -

Eric Walch wrote:

Yes, it was only in the original example that smoothing was a bad option. In general it gives good effects. But you must use smoothing groups. In wings that is done by enclosing a to be smoothed area with hard edges (show yellow in wings). To be effective the area must be fully enclosed by the hard edges.
I have no idea how this works in blender, as when I imported a obj file with hard edges, and imported it into blender, I got the impression those edges were lost again.